Rubric

Keep in mind that 23 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Lyft Focus Group
Lyft Focus Group
Criteria Ratings Pts
Writing Proficiency
threshold: pts
20 pts Outstanding Correct grammar throughout, minimal errors. Clear, concise, highly-professional wording.
18 pts Excellent Correct grammar throughout, minor number of errors. Mostly professional wording.
16 pts Mostly Satisfactory More than a minor number of grammatical errors, but still clear. May lack professional wording on a few occasions.
14 pts Marginal Several grammatical errors that detract from readability. May contain some unclear, informal, or unprofessional wording.
0 pts No Points Poor grammar is pervasive. Wording is confusing, informal/ inappropriate, or overly verbose.
pts
20 pts
--
Depth and Consistency
threshold: pts
40 pts Full Marks Report provides thorough, well-explained responses to all questions posed by Lyft.
36 pts Excellent Responses to most questions are thorough and well-explained with some very minor areas of weakness.
32 pts Mostly Satisfactory Responses are mixed, with some being excellent and others lacking depth or not as well explained as possible.
28 pts Marginal Responses have some value but with multiple areas of weakness or lack of depth.
0 pts No Points Report shows very little effort and is unlikely to be valuable to the company.
pts
40 pts
--
Brainstorming Originality
threshold: pts
20 pts Outstanding Report shows a genuine effort to provide unique and innovative input to the company.
17 pts Satisfactory Report reflects a solid effort to provide some unique ideas to the company.
14 pts Marginal Report shows limited effort to provide unique ideas.
0 pts No Points Report shows very limited to no effort to brainstorm ideas.
pts
20 pts
--
Professionalism of Presentation
threshold: pts
20 pts Outstanding Report includes appropriate graphs, tables, and other exhibits. Likely finalist to be sent to Lyft.
17 pts Satisfactory Report contains some evidence of efforts to display the information in a professional manner.
14 pts Marginal Report shows limited effort to display the information in a professional manner.
0 pts No Points Report shows very limited to no effort to display the information in a professional manner.
pts
20 pts
--