Rubric

Keep in mind that 19 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
KIND Case Rubric (2)
KIND Case Rubric (2)
Criteria Ratings Pts
Writing Proficiency
threshold: pts
30 pts Outstanding Correct grammar throughout, minimal errors. Clear, concise, highly-professional and persuasive wording.
25 pts Very Good Correct grammar throughout, minor number of errors. Mostly professional wording that is reasonably persuasive.
20 pts Mixed Proficiency More than a minor number of grammatical errors, but still clear. May occasionally lack professional wording or have a somewhat limited persuasive character.
15 pts Marginal to Weak Several grammatical errors that detract from readability. Significant unclear, informal, or unprofessional wording.
0 pts No Points Poor grammar is pervasive. Wording is confusing, informal/ inappropriate, or overly verbose.
pts
30 pts
--
Logical Defense of Categories Retained vs Cut
threshold: pts
50 pts Full Marks Memo provides a thorough and well-reasoned recommendation for the company to consider.
45 pts Excellent Memo provides logical support for the recommendation, but may may be slightly off base in some aspect of the logic.
40 pts Mostly Satisfactory Recommendation has merit but explanation is not entirely convincing.
35 pts Marginal The defense of the recommendation provided in the memo is either illogical or the explanation of it is significantly lacking.
0 pts No Points Memo reflects very little effort and is unlikely to be of any value to the company.
pts
50 pts
--
Professionalism of Presentation
threshold: pts
20 pts Outstanding Memo has the appearance of a top-quality business letter of which any employee would be proud.
17 pts Satisfactory Memo shows efforts to display the information in a professional manner but falls short in 1-2 ways.
14 pts Marginal Memo shows limited effort to display the information in a professional manner.
0 pts No Points Memo shows very limited to no effort to display the information in a professional manner.
pts
20 pts
--